Cincinnati · Est. Over-the-Rhine

Handcrafted cookies,
baked with intention

Small-batch, artisan cookies made from scratch each day — rich, buttery, and thoughtfully flavored for the discerning sweet tooth.

Explore Our Cookies Visit Our Kitchen
Scroll
Freshly baked cookies on a wooden surface

Our Story

A devotion to the
perfect cookie

Gaslight Gourmet Cookies was born from a simple belief: that a cookie should be more than a snack. It should be an experience — crisp at the edges, chewy in the center, layered with flavor that lingers.

Every batch is mixed by hand in our Over-the-Rhine kitchen, using premium chocolate, real butter, and flavors sourced with care. We don't rush the process, and we don't compromise on ingredients.

Whether you're stopping by for a single warm cookie or planning a custom order for a celebration, we bring the same attention to detail to every bag we hand you.

100%
From Scratch
Daily
Fresh Baked
15+
Flavors

Our Cookies

Signature Batches

Rotating selections baked fresh each morning. Ask about today's specials and seasonal flavors at the counter.

Dark chocolate chip cookie

Dark Chocolate Chunk

Valrhona chocolate chunks in a brown-butter base, finished with Maldon salt. Our most requested.

Strawberry white chocolate cookie

Strawberry White Choc

Dehydrated strawberry pieces folded into white chocolate dough — bright, tart, and deeply satisfying.

Matcha cookie with white chocolate chips

Matcha White Chocolate

Ceremonial-grade matcha swirled into a tender dough with white chocolate chips. Earthy and delicate.

Maple brown sugar cookie

Maple Brown Sugar

Pure maple syrup in every bite, with a caramelized center and a whisper of vanilla bean.

Lavender honey cookie

Lavender Honey

culinary lavender and local honey create a floral, comforting cookie that feels like a warm evening.

Sea salt dark chocolate cookie

Sea Salt Dark Chocolate

70% single-origin dark chocolate with flaky sea salt. Bold, balanced, and impossible to eat just one.

The Experience

More than a cookie shop

01

Watch Them Make It

Our open kitchen lets you see every step — mixing, portioning, baking. Fresh from the oven is always the best seat in the house.

02

Custom Orders

Weddings, birthdays, corporate gifts — we craft cookie boxes tailored to your event. Flavor selections, packaging, and quantities to match.

03

A Place to Stay

Pull up a chair. Enjoy your cookie with a coffee or tea, or take it home to savor later. Either way, it's an occasion.

Visit Us

Come say hello

Get in Touch

Address
272 Ludlow Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45220
Hours
Monday – Friday 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sunday 9:00 AM – 5:00 PM

Special Occasions

Let us make your
next celebration sweeter

From intimate gatherings to large events, we create custom cookie orders with your flavors, your packaging, and your timeline in mind.

Call (151) 387-7777
Is this your business? This is my business